Tuesday, April 22, 2025

Some college presidents express an opinion.

Our colleges and universities share a commitment to serve as centers of open inquiry where, in their pursuit of truth, faculty, students, and staff are free to exchange ideas and opinions across a full range of viewpoints without fear of retribution, censorship, or deportation. . . . 

Signed,

Jonathan Alger, President, American University
Suzanne Ames, President, Peninsula College
Carmen Twillie Ambar, President, Oberlin College
Denise A. Battles, President, SUNY Geneseo
Ian Baucom, Incoming President, Middlebury College
Allan Belton, President, Pacific Lutheran University
Hubert Benitez, President, Saint Peter's University 
Joanne Berger-Sweeney, President, Trinity College (CT)
Michael A. Bernstein, President, The College of New Jersey
Audrey Bilger, President, Reed College 
Erik J. Bitterbaum, President, SUNY Cortland
Sarah Bolton, President, Whitman College
Mary H. Bonderoff, President, SUNY Delhi
Eric Boynton, President, Beloit College
Elizabeth H. Bradley, President, Vassar College
Brian Bruess, President, College of Saint Benedict and Saint John's University
Adam Bush, President, College Unbound
Alison Byerly, President, Carleton College
Wendy Cadge, President and Professor of Sociology, Bryn Mawr College
Nancy Cantor, President, Hunter College CUNY
Alberto Jose Cardelle, President, SUNY Oneonta
Brian W. Casey, President, Colgate University
Ana Mari Cauce, Professor and President, University of Washington
Andrea Chapdelaine, President, Connecticut College
Thom D. Chesney, President, Southwestern College (NM)
Bryan F. Coker, President, Maryville College 
Ronald B. Cole, President, Allegheny College
Jennifer Collins, President, Rhodes College
John Comerford, President, Otterbein University
Marc C. Conner, President, Skidmore College
La Jerne Terry Cornish, President, Ithaca College
Grant Cornwell, President, Rollins College
Isiaah Crawford, President, University of Puget Sound
Gregory G. Dell'Omo, President, Rider University
Kent Devereaux, President, Goucher College
Jim Dlugos, Interim President, Landmark College
Bethami Dobkin, President, Westminster University
Harry Dumay, President, Elms College
Christopher L. Eisgruber, President, Princeton University
Michael A. Elliott, President, Amherst College
Jane Fernandes, President, Antioch College
Damian J. Fernandez, President, Warren Wilson College
David Fithian, President, Clark University
Lisa C. Freeman, President, Northern Illinois University
Robert Gaines, Acting President, Pomona College
Alan M. Garber, President, Harvard University
Michael H. Gavin, President, Delta College
Mark D. Gearan, President, Hobart and William Smith Colleges
Melissa Gilliam, President, Boston University
Jorge G. Gonzalez, President, Kalamazoo College
Jonathan D. Green, President, Susquehanna University
David A. Greene, President, Colby College
William R. Groves, Chancellor, Antioch University
Jeremy Haefner, Chancellor, University of Denver
Yoshiko Harden, President, Renton Technical College
Anne F. Harris, President, Grinnell College
James T. Harris, President, University of San Diego
Marjorie Hass, President, Council of Independent Colleges 
Richard J. Helldobler, President, William Paterson University
Wendy Hensel, President, University of Hawaii
James Herbert, President, University of New England
Doug Hicks, President, Davidson College
Mary Dana Hinton, President, Hollins University 
Jonathan Holloway, President, Rutgers University
Robin Holmes-Sullivan, President, Lewis & Clark College
Robert H. Huntington, President, Heidelberg University 
Nicole Hurd, President, Lafayette College
Wolde-Ab Isaac, Chancellor, Riverside Community College District
Karim Ismaili, President, Eastern Connecticut State University
J. Larry Jameson, President, University of Pennsylvania
Garry W. Jenkins, President, Bates College
Paula A. Johnson, President, Wellesley College
John E. Jones III, President, Dickinson College
Cristle Collins Judd, President, Sarah Lawrence College
David L. Kaufman, President, Capital University
Colleen Perry Keith, President, Goldey-Beacom College
Julie Johnson Kidd, President, Endeavor Foundation
Jonathan Koppell, President, Montclair State University
Sally Kornbluth, President, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Julie Kornfeld, President, Kenyon College
Michael I. Kotlikoff, President, Cornell University
Paula Krebs, Executive Director, Modern Language Association
Sunil Kumar, President, Tufts University
Bobbie Laur, President, Campus Compact
Frederick M. Lawrence, Secretary and CEO, Phi Beta Kappa Society
Hilary L. Link, President, Drew University
Patricia A. Lynott, President, Rockford University
Heidi Macpherson, President, SUNY Brockport
John Maduko, President, Connecticut State Community College
Lynn Mahoney, President, San Francisco State University
Daniel Mahony, President, Southern Illinois University 
Maud S. Mandel, President, Williams College
Christine Mangino, President, Queensborough Community College
Amy Marcus-Newhall, President, Scripps College
Felix V. Matos-Rodriguez, Chancellor, City University of New York (CUNYAnne E. McCall, President, The College of Wooster
Richard L. McCormick, Interim President, Stony Brook University
Michael McDonald, President, Great Lakes Colleges Association
James McGrath, President and Dean, Cooley Law School
Patricia McGuire, President, Trinity Washington University
Maurie McInnis, President, Yale University
Elizabeth M. Meade, President, Cedar Crest College
Scott D. Miller, President, Virginia Wesleyan University
Jennifer Mnookin, Chancellor, University of Wisconsin–Madison
Robert Mohrbacher, President, Centralia College
Chris Moody, Executive Director, ACPA-College Student Educators International
Tomas Morales, President, California State University San Bernardino
Milton Moreland, President, Centre College
Kathryn Morris, President, St. Lawrence University
Ross Mugler, Board Chair and Acting President and CEO, Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges
Krista L. Newkirk, President, University of Redlands
Stefanie D. Niles, President, Cottey College
Claire Oliveros, President, Riverside City College
Robyn Parker, Interim President, Saybrook University
Lynn Pasquerella, President, American Association of Colleges and Universities
Laurie L. Patton, President, American Academy of Arts and Sciences
Beth Paul, President, Nazareth University
Christina Paxson, President, Brown University
Rob Pearigen, Vice-Chancellor and President, University of the South
Deidra Peaslee, President, Saint Paul College
Eduardo M. Peñalver, President, Seattle University
Ora Pescovitz, President, Oakland University
Darryll J. Pines, President, University of Maryland
Nicola Pitchford, President, Dominican University of California
Kevin Pollock, President, Central Carolina Technical College 
Susan Poser, President, Hofstra University
Paul C. Pribbenow, President, Augsburg University
Vincent Price, President, Duke University
Robert Quinn, Executive Director, Scholars at Risk Network
Wendy E. Raymond, President, Haverford College
Christopher M. Reber, President, Hudson County Community College 
Suzanne M. Rivera, President, Macalester College - Saint Paul, MN ( MBR )
Michael S. Roth, President, Wesleyan University
James Ryan, President, University of Virginia
Vincent Rougeau, President, College of the Holy Cross
Kurt L. Schmoke, President, University of Baltimore
Carol Geary Schneider, Acting Executive Director, Civic Learning and Democracy Engagement Coalition
Sean M. Scott, President and Dean, California Western School of Law
Zaldwaynaka Scott, President, Chicago State University
Philip J. Sisson, President, Middlesex Community College (MA)
Suzanne Smith, President, SUNY Potsdam
Valerie Smith, President, Swarthmore College
Paul Sniegowski, President, Earlham College
Barbara R. Snyder, President, Association of American Universities
Stephen Snyder, Interim President, Middlebury College
Weymouth Spence, President, Washington Adventist University
Terri Standish-Kuon, President and CEO, Independent Colleges of Washington
G. Gabrielle Starr, President, Pomona College 
Karen A. Stout, President, Achieving the Dream
Tom Stritikus, President, Occidental College
Julie Sullivan, President, Santa Clara University 
Aondover Tarhule, President, Illinois State University
Glena Temple, President, Dominican University
Steven J. Tepper. President, Hamilton College
Kellye Y. Testy, CEO, Association of American Law Schools
Tania Tetlow, President, Fordham University
Strom C. Thacker, President, Pitzer College
Scott L. Thomas, President, Sterling College 
Deborah Trautman, President and CEO, American Association of Colleges of Nursing
Satish K. Tripathi, President, University at Buffalo, SUNY
Kyaw Moe Tun, President, Parami University
Brad Tyndall, President, Central Wyoming College
LaTanya Tyson, President, Carolina Christian College
Matthew P. vandenBerg, President, Ohio Wesleyan University
James Vander Hooven, President, Mount Wachusett Community College
Laura R. Walker, President, Bennington College
Yolanda Watson Spiva, President, Complete College America 
Michaele Whelan, President, Wheaton College
Manya C. Whitaker, Interim President, Colorado College
Julie A. Manley White, Chancellor and CEO, Pierce College
Kim A. Wilcox, Chancellor, University of California, Riverside
Sarah Willie-LeBreton, President, Smith College
Safa R. Zaki, President, Bowdoin College

Source:

Friday, April 11, 2025

She Worked in a Harvard Lab to Reverse Aging, Until ICE Jailed Her [ NYTimes ]

The flava:
Dr. Peshkin’s team is interested in sperm and egg cells, and how they repair damage as an embryo develops. They needed someone equally fluent in machine learning and cell biology, Dr. Peshkin explained in a post on Kaggle, an online community for data scientists. Ms. Petrova reached out.

When she arrived in Boston in May 2023, Dr. Peshkin was shocked to discover that she had not brought a suitcase; she carried a backpack. It became clear, he said, that she was “extremely ascetic,” entirely wrapped up in her research.

“I thought the Russia of my childhood was gone, the Russia of this crazy, dedicated, ascetic scientist is gone,” he said. Over the months that followed, Dr. Peshkin watched her focus intensely for many hours; he saw what she could pull off in a few days of coding. “She is probably strongest I’ve seen,” he said. “I am at Harvard for 20 years.”

Ms. Petrova found ways to speed up everyone’s work. . . . 

The article:

Thursday, April 10, 2025

Wiley journal retracts over 200 more papers [ Retraction Watch ]

The flava:
The International Wound Journal has retracted 242 papers so far this year as part of an ongoing investigation into manipulated peer review. . . .  


The article:

Wednesday, April 9, 2025

They came to the US for degrees. They fear being deported without them. [ csmonitor.com ]

The flava:
“If the United States government has national security concerns regarding a student and they feel that their visa should be revoked, they are within their rights to do that. But we are really trying to understand, in this new environment, what does that mean? What are these students doing that is triggering a national security concern?” says Sarah Spreitzer, assistant vice president at the American Council on Education, which advocates for 1,600 colleges and universities.

Most international college students hold F-1 visas and are allowed to enroll as full-time students. They are allowed to travel in and out of the country, and enjoy most constitutional rights. They cannot vote or receive federal financial aid or other government benefits.

International students have brought a financial boon to both universities and the overall U.S. economy. In a 2023-2024 school year analysis, 1.1 million international students added $43.8 billion to the economy and supported 378,175 jobs, the NAFSA Association of International Educators found. That was up from $26 billion a decade ago. Ms. Spreitzer is concerned that current policies could send students and researchers looking for berths in Canada or Europe instead. . . . 

The article:

Thursday, April 3, 2025

Postdoc Named Helen Hay Whitney Fellow [ Stowers Institute for Medical Research ]

College student reflects on impact of viral online rumor that 'ruined' her life [ NBC News ]

Ten weeks that shook the world [ Financial Times ]

The flava:
On many fronts, and with deliberate haste, America is vaporising its soft power. It takes less than a quarter to besmirch a brand that took a quarter of a millennium to build. How long would it take to repair? Last week, Myanmar was hit by its worst earthquake in decades. Chinese and even Russian aid teams were on the ground within days. Having dismantled USAID, American assistance has yet to arrive. At home, Trump plans to deport more than 300,000 Venezuelan refugees into the maw of the brutal regime they fled. 

None of the world’s huddled masses are welcome in America with one exception — white South Africans. As Trump shuts down agencies and consulates around the world, his administration is establishing processing centres for white Afrikaner “refugees” in Pretoria, who he claims are victims of racial discrimination by South Africa’s Black majority government. In case anyone misses the point, his administration is erasing the contributions of non-white Americans from Pentagon websites, the Arlington cemetery and the Smithsonian museum. Martin Luther King Jr is out. The names of defeated confederate generals are back. Science research projects are being scoured for banned words, such as “equity” and even “women”. 

All of this is being done in the name of meritocracy. America’s new guard are almost all white, all male, and mostly unqualified to lead the great departments they are vandalising. It is not just foreigners who are remaking their plans. American scientists are looking for jobs abroad. Trump has presented the rest of the world with a giant poaching opportunity. . . .   

The article:

Wednesday, April 2, 2025

How Each Pillar of the 1st Amendment is Under Attack [ krebsonsecurity.com ]

The flava:
In an address to Congress this month, President Trump claimed he had “brought free speech back to America.” But barely two months into his second term, the president has waged an unprecedented attack on the First Amendment rights of journalists, students, universities, government workers, lawyers and judges.

This story explores a slew of recent actions by the Trump administration that threaten to undermine all five pillars of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which guarantees freedoms concerning speech, religion, the media, the right to assembly, and the right to petition the government and seek redress for wrongs. . . . 

The article:

Monday, March 31, 2025

Opinion by Michael I. Kotlikoff

Cornell University recently hosted an event that any reputable P.R. firm would surely have advised against. On a calm campus, in a semester unroiled by protest, we chose to risk stirring the waters by organizing a panel discussion that brought together Israeli and Palestinian voices with an in-person audience open to all.

We held the event in our largest campus space, promoted it widely and devoted significant resources to hosting Salam Fayyad, a former prime minister of the Palestinian Authority; Tzipi Livni, a former vice prime minister and foreign minister of Israel; and Daniel B. Shapiro, a former United States ambassador to Israel, in a discussion moderated by Ryan Crocker, a career diplomat and former U.S. ambassador to countries in some of the world’s most combustible regions.

The week before, I extended a personal invitation to our student community, explaining that open inquiry “is the antidote to corrosive narratives” and is what enables us “to see and respect other views, work together across differences and conceive of solutions to intractable problems.”

Was I surprised when the discussion was almost immediately interrupted by protest? Disappointed, yes, but not surprised or deterred. We had expected it and were prepared. The few students and staff members who had come only to disrupt were warned, warned again and then swiftly removed. They now face university discipline.

Inside the auditorium, the event went on as planned. . . . 

--Michael I. Kotlikoff, president of Cornell University and professor of molecular physiology.

Source:

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Most college students are taking online classes, but they’re paying just as much as in-person students [ hechingerreport.org ]

The flava:
Emma Bittner considered getting a master’s degree in public health at a nearby university, but the in-person program cost tens of thousands of dollars more than she had hoped to spend.

So she checked out master’s degrees she could pursue remotely, on her laptop, which she was sure would be much cheaper.

The price for the same degree, online, was … just as much. Or more.

“I’m, like, what makes this worth it?” said Bittner, 25, who lives in Austin, Texas. “Why does it cost that much if I don’t get meetings face-to-face with the professor or have the experience in person?”

Among the surprising answers is that colleges and universities are charging more for online education to subsidize everything else they do, online managers say. Huge sums are also going into marketing and advertising for it, documents show.

The article:

Monday, March 17, 2025

How Niche Programs Are Saving Higher Education [ Forbes ]

The flava: 
Higher education institutions must rethink their strategies to stay relevant in today's increasingly competitive landscape. As enrollment numbers dwindle, financial pressures mount, and competition from alternative education options rises, many schools seek ways to differentiate themselves. Higher education institutions marketed themselves for decades as one-size-fits-all solutions, offering broad liberal arts curricula and traditional majors. However, a new strategy is emerging as the landscape shifts: niche programs catering to high-demand, specialized fields. One of the most effective ways to do so is by offering specialized programs not widely available elsewhere. In an era where niche knowledge and skill sets are in high demand, universities that cater to specific industries or unique interests can position themselves as leaders in their fields. . . . 

The article:

Thursday, March 13, 2025

Lee Bollinger presents his thoughts







--Lee Bollinger, former president of Columbia University and the University of Michigan

podcasts this week: Grammar Girl, Fresh Air, & The Key with Inside Higher Ed


Wednesday, March 12, 2025

Local college students give up spring break to give back [ WOOD TV8 ]

Education Department Lays Off Nearly Half of Staff [ Inside Higher Ed ]

The flava:
The Education Department laid off “nearly 50 percent” of its more than 4,100 employees Tuesday evening, according to four sources inside the agency who were told about the plans and an agency news release. . . . 

The reductions will bring the total workforce down to fewer than 2,200. 

The department’s D.C. offices will be closed Wednesday for “security reasons,” according to an email obtained by Inside Higher Ed. The email instructed department staff to take their laptops home with them on Tuesday in order to telework Wednesday, and said they would “not be permitted in any ED facility on Wednesday, March 12th, for any reason.” 

The article:

Thursday, March 6, 2025

As Trump Goes After Universities, Students Are Now on the Chopping Block [ NYTimes ]

The flava:
In the early weeks of the Trump administration’s push to slash funding that colleges and universities rely on, grants and contracts had been cut and, in a few cases, researchers had been laid off.

In recent days, the fiscal pain has come to students.

At the University of Pennsylvania, administrators have asked departments in the School of Arts & Sciences, the university’s largest school, to cut incoming Ph.D. students. In some cases, that meant reneging on informal offers, according to Wendy Roth, a professor of sociology.

Her department had to decide which of the students would be “unaccepted.” Dr. Roth, chair of graduate education, was chosen to explain those decisions to them.

“Two of them, I would say, were extremely upset. One person was in tears,” she said. “It’s just the most terrible thing to get that kind of news when your plans are made.”

Since taking office, the Trump administration has issued orders that threaten to broadly undercut the financial foundation of university based research, including deep reductions in overhead cost reimbursements through the National Institutes of Health. Court challenges have paused some of the cuts, but universities are bracing for uncertainty. The University of Pennsylvania could face a $250 million hit in N.I.H. funding alone. . . . 

The article:

Tuesday, March 4, 2025

Trump threatens to pull federal funds for US schools allowing ‘illegal protests’ [ The Guardian ]

The flava:
Donald Trump threatened on Tuesday to halt all federal funding for any college or school that allows “illegal protests” and vowed to imprison “agitators”, in a social media statement that prompted alarm from free expression advocates.

“All Federal Funding will STOP for any College, School, or University that allows illegal protests,” the US president wrote on Truth Social.

“Agitators will be imprisoned/or permanently sent back to the country from which they came. American students will be permanently expelled or, depending on on [sic] the crime, arrested. NO MASKS! Thank you for your attention to this matter.”

In a statement on Tuesday, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (Fire) condemned Trump’s remarks. . . . 

The article:

Thursday, February 27, 2025

:-)

Hoehne Alamosa Piedra Platner Yuma 😊 Brush Idalia Rollinsville Telluride Hotchkiss Downieville Almont Yoder  😊  Crestone Agate Limon   



Thursday, February 20, 2025

The crisis facing colleges and universities that no one is talking about [ thebigstorypodcast.ca ]

There is a crisis facing Canada’s post-secondary education sector that no one is talking about.

Now that the federal government has slashed the number of international student permits available in Canada, colleges and universities from coast to coast are facing huge budget shortfalls.

Several of Canada’s best schools are cutting programs and laying off staff just to stay afloat.

These institutions have no choice but to take drastic measures, or risk going bankrupt.

PhD student expelled from University of Minnesota for allegedly using AI [ KARE 11 ]

Friday, February 7, 2025

5 Ways the Education Department Affects Higher Ed [ insidehighered.com ]

The flava:
Republicans’ long-sought goal of shuttering the Education Department got a boost this week as several media outlets reported the Trump administration was finalizing plans for an executive order to wind down the agency.

Trump added to the speculation, telling reporters Tuesday he wanted his education secretary nominee, Linda McMahon, to put herself out of a job. Then, on Wednesday, House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, said getting rid of the department is “an idea whose time has come.”

The specifics and timing of the executive order are still unclear, though media reports say the directive could instruct department officials to shut down some programs not directly approved by Congress or come up with a plan to move functions to other departments in the federal government. At the very least, the Trump administration wants to see a much smaller version of the department, particularly because only Congress can actually eliminate the agency.

More than 4,000 people currently work for the department, which was created in 1979. In fiscal year 2024, the department had a $80 billion discretionary budget. Its spending makes up just over 2 percent of the federal budget. . . . 

The article:

Wednesday, February 5, 2025

‘Merit based, color blind’: Race, sex no longer considered for military promotions and academy admissions as Hegseth moves to weed out DEI [ Stars and Stripes ]

The flava:
Race and sex will no longer be considered in military promotions and academy admissions as Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth moves to weed out diversity and equity-based programs across the U.S. military.

“The [Defense Department] will strive to provide merit-based, color-blind, equal opportunities to service members but will not guarantee or strive for equal outcomes,” Hegseth wrote in a memo released Wednesday titled “Restoring America’s Fighting Force.”

According to the memo, the Defense Department will not take into account sex, race or ethnicity when considering troops for promotions or special duty. Additionally, no department component will establish sex-, race- or ethnicity-based goals for academic admissions, career fields or organizational composition. . . . 

The article:

The college affordability crisis [ WAMU ]

Thursday, January 30, 2025

Fake papers are contaminating the world’s scientific literature, fueling a corrupt industry and slowing legitimate lifesaving medical research [ The Conversation ]

The flava:
Over the past decade, furtive commercial entities around the world have industrialized the production, sale and dissemination of bogus scholarly research, undermining the literature that everyone from doctors to engineers rely on to make decisions about human lives.

It is exceedingly difficult to get a handle on exactly how big the problem is. Around 55,000 scholarly papers have been retracted to date, for a variety of reasons, but scientists and companies who screen the scientific literature for telltale signs of fraud estimate that there are many more fake papers circulating – possibly as many as several hundred thousand. This fake research can confound legitimate researchers who must wade through dense equations, evidence, images and methodologies only to find that they were made up.

Even when the bogus papers are spotted – usually by amateur sleuths on their own time – academic journals are often slow to retract the papers, allowing the articles to taint what many consider sacrosanct: the vast global library of scholarly work that introduces new ideas, reviews other research and discusses findings.

The article:

Thursday, January 23, 2025

Screens Have Taken Over Classrooms. Even Students Have Had Enough. [ WSJ ]

The flava:
Class time has become screen time in American schools.

Kindergartners now watch math lessons on YouTube, counting aloud with the videos. Middle-schoolers complete writing drills on Chromebooks while sneaking in play of an online game. High-schoolers mark up Google Docs to finish group projects. 

The rapid tech transformation amounts to a grand experiment playing out in American schools. Accelerated by pandemic-era online learning, the move has happened with little debate, conflicting research and high stakes for the nation’s children. 

Educators wonder whether the digitization of the classroom has really benefited learning—or if it’s done kids a disservice. Some teachers say online tools help create more engaging lessons and provide personalized instruction. Others say the screen-heavy approach has distracted students and burned out teachers

“Covid really shifted things toward, ‘Oh, we can do this,’” said Stephanie Galvani, a middle-school English teacher in suburban Boston. “But we didn’t ask: ‘Should we do this?’”

The shift runs counter to the prevailing advice from doctors and psychologists to limit tech use. Some frustrated parents are trying to opt their kids out of school technology, with varying degrees of success. Even some students pine for more analog methods. . . .

The article:

Tuesday, January 14, 2025

Report Was In Error: Freshman Enrollment Did Not Decline 5% Last Fall [ Forbes ]

The flava:

The National Student Clearinghouse Research Center today released the following statement from Executive Director Doug Shapiro about an error that affected the freshman enrollment data in its October preliminary fall enrollment report:

“The National Student Clearinghouse Research Center has identified a methodological error affecting its calculation of freshman enrollment in the preliminary enrollment report released in October 2024. That report, called the Stay Informed Report, is based on data provided by 50 percent of higher education institutions. The error in research methodology caused the mislabeling of certain students as dual-enrolled rather than as freshmen, and as a result, the number of freshmen was undercounted, and the number of dual-enrolled was overcounted. The error also affected the Special Analysis of 18-year-old Freshmen report released in November.”

The initially reported 5% drop in freshman enrollment was widely covered in news outlets and cited by numerous commentators over the past few months. . . .  

The article:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2025/01/13/report-was-in-error-freshman-enrollment-did-not-decline-5-last-fall/

Sunday, January 12, 2025

John Aubrey Douglass: Leading a university is set to become even more difficult.





--John Aubrey Douglass, senior research fellow for public policy and higher education at the Center for Studies in Higher Education, Goldman School of Public Policy, University of California, Berkeley