I had a nice moment during office hours today—I’ll get to it. It stems from our department’s current major basket-weaving project, a subset of basket-weaving that isn’t my specialty, but I’m finding myself more and more immersed in it, since our department is putting together a graduate program in this kind of basket-weaving. The project has unearthed a few concerns, which I’m having trouble articulating except in a place like this.
So the project is a kind of basket-weaving that the participants devise over a period of weeks and then present, and it’s never been my thing, exactly. And I’m not in a position anymore where I could just say, well, I admire the concept, but it’s not my kind of basket-weaving, or I’m not the intended basket-weaving audience—I pretty much have to cheerlead for it. I’m learning some of the vocabulary, but I’m not sure my heart is in it. And I’m starting to worry a bit that our department is going to break its arm patting itself on the back with regard to how “courageous” this kind of basket-weaving is. Some of it really is courageous, and some of it is kind of… basket-weaving wanking, I think. (I suppose there is some courage involved in wanking, at that.)
I find myself at a great loss in terms of how to explain it or put it in context for the non-basket-weaving majors, and yet there may be a key—remember that “nice moment” I mentioned 215 words ago? A non-major from my intro to basket-weaving lecture course expressed concerns about giving a written response to the project, since the project confused her. My admission was pretty simple: “You’re not the only one, sweet cheeks.” (For the record, I did not really say “sweet cheeks.”) I assured the student that she didn’t have to get the details “right” or “wrong”—most of it was perception and opinion. We talked through a few of the basics of the project that I knew about, and we came to some plausible conclusions. “That was very helpful,” she said. “Thank you.”
Lately, I’ve been feeling not quite part of the basket-weaving team—more like I’m “basket-weaving adjacent.” I can take steps to improve that. But a word or two like that from a student who really wants to take intro to basket-weaving seriously—it’s something. Some of my other students, who get most of their philosophy from Pixar (as do I, I must readily admit), tell me to “just keep swimming.” I’ll do that, too.
Finally, I read a Yaro piece—something about a goodbye party thrown by his grateful and loving colleagues and former students. It was sweet.
I had to use The Google to discover that George Leroy Tirebiter was the Californian equivalent of Texas A&M's Reveille. And I'm glad the author found the piece about Yaro's good-bye party to be sweet. There are real people behind these avatars and nicknames. Yaro was pretty magnificent.
ReplyDeleteI'd heard of G.L. Tirebiter but forgotten he was replaced by a horse.
DeleteIt's interesting to learn the background of GLT--I'll admit I was only thinking of the protagonist of Firesign Theater's "Don't Crush That Dwarf, Hand Me the Pliers."
ReplyDeleteWelcome, Dr. Tirebiter. Based on the information above, I will have to google your name. In the meantime, I wanted to say that I like your profile pic. It reminds me of the family backstory early in Charlotte Temple, where we meet a gentleman in reduced circumstances.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you had a good moment with a student. I find puzzling things I don't entirely understand through with students who don't entirely understand them either (though from a somewhat different perspective) can often be rewarding. This is fortunate, since I'm a literature scholar mostly teaching writing to scientists these days. Some combination of nurturing intellectual curiosity (I know a surprising amount about driverless cars, cybersecurity, and assorted other technical subjects) and reminding myself that I'm not teaching them a subject, I'm teaching them how to learn on their own, seems to work (at least on some days. For the other days, I recommend patting that nice dog beside you.)
Thanks, Dr. Cassandra... as it happens, I didn't choose the picture--probably the work of the RGM, but I like it a lot, too. And I spend a lot of time petting my real-life cat.
ReplyDelete